• About us
  • Donate
  • WADR
  • Contact us
  • Live Stream
Friday, April 25, 2025
Loud Silence News
Advertisement
  • Ghana News
    • General News
    • Business
    • Education
    • Opinion
  • US News
    • Business
    • Health
    • Human Interest Stories
    • Politics
    • Education
  • Africa News
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
    • Politics
  • ShowBiz
    • Ghana ShowBiz
    • US Showbiz
    • African ShowBiz
    • World Showbiz
  • Editorials
    • People
  • World News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
  • Sports
    • Ghana Sports
    • World Sports
  • WADR
No Result
View All Result
  • Ghana News
    • General News
    • Business
    • Education
    • Opinion
  • US News
    • Business
    • Health
    • Human Interest Stories
    • Politics
    • Education
  • Africa News
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
    • Politics
  • ShowBiz
    • Ghana ShowBiz
    • US Showbiz
    • African ShowBiz
    • World Showbiz
  • Editorials
    • People
  • World News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
  • Sports
    • Ghana Sports
    • World Sports
  • WADR
No Result
View All Result
Loud Silence News
No Result
View All Result
Home US News US Health

The Takeaways From Seroprevalence Surveys

Loud Silence Staff by Loud Silence Staff
May 5, 2020
in US Health
0
Why Clinicians’ Spiritual Health Matters in the COVID-19 Crisis
4
SHARES
23
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsApp

[ad_1]


What your doctor is reading on Medscape.com:

MAY 04, 2020 — Medscape has asked top experts to weigh in on the most pressing scientific questions about COVID-19, starting with serology studies. We’ll have more COVID Data Dives from Dr. Dean and another expert later this week.

It’s easier to poke holes in a study than to run one yourself. We should expect many more SARS-CoV-2 serosurveys in our future. So, in the spirit of promoting good science, here are my thoughts on best practices for the design of serosurveys.

First, it is critical to remember that serosurveys are population-level surveys. They are intended to inform our broader understanding of the disease, not to tell individuals whether they have or have not been infected. The tests are still too unreliable for the latter.

Serosurveys are particularly useful in that they allow us to reconstruct the past. We expect that many mild infections are being missed because of insufficient testing capacity, and we are confident that the vast majority of asymptomatic infections are missed. By using antibody tests to look back at who has previously been infected, we can link this with known case counts to estimate the proportion of infections detected. Some experts say that 1 out of 10 or 1 out of 20 infections are detected, though some surveys have reported higher counts.

Given that we know that many infections are being missed, we might wonder what proportion of the total population has been infected. This can be used to address questions about “herd immunity.” Of note, though, we will need more evidence that having antibodies means you are immune, and that reinfection does not occur. So far, levels of antibody in populations studied have been low. We are seeing numbers only above single digits in hard-hit areas, indicating that we are far from the 60%-70% threshold for herd immunity.

We can use serosurveys to estimate the infection fatality ratio (IFR). Serosurveys let us estimate the full denominator of people infected rather than just PCR-confirmed cases. The crude case fatality ratio (CFR) is known to be an overestimate because testing is often reserved for the sickest patients. When we include mild or even asymptomatic infections, this number drops. Best estimates of IFR seem to be hovering around 0.5%-1.0%, although more data are emerging.


Continued

IFR is just an average, and we know that risk varies a lot across age groups. Another major scientific goal is to determine age-specific infection probabilities and, thus, age-specific IFR. This can be achieved if there is good survey coverage across age groups.

When thinking about designing a serosurvey to target a geographic region, it may make logistical sense to select a few smaller sub-areas to study. For example, we might select four to five areas ranging from most hard-hit (assessed by cases and deaths) to least hard-hit, to establish a range. Often we are most interested in capturing hard-hit areas because these will have the biggest numbers infected to support estimating overall and age-specific IFR.

The best survey designs are household-based with random selection of households. All persons in a selected household are invited to participate to get a broad range of ages. Including entire households also allows us to assess transmissibility within households. Household designs, while less prone to bias, are not immune as not everyone will consent to participate or be home. Essential workers, for example, may be harder to recruit than those who are sheltering in place. These studies also take more time to set up and run, and it is vital that survey teams are provided with adequate personal protective equipment when going to homes.

In a survey conducted in Miami, random digit dialing was used to recruit a representative sample of participants. Participants then agreed to visit a drive-thru testing site. Bias can still occur if people do not consent or do not have a car, but it’s a creative approach.

Volunteer surveys are a type of convenience sample. Santa Clara investigators used targeted Facebook ads to recruit participants to visit drive-thru test sites. Quotas were established per zip code to limit overrepresentation. The National Institutes of Health’s (NIH’s) survey in Bethesda, Maryland , is also volunteer-based. Questionnaire data are collected over the phone. Participants who are NIH employees are tested on site, and others are provided with a kit for home-based blood draw.

An obvious concern with volunteer surveys is that people will preferentially enroll because they think they had COVID-19 and want confirmation. Notably, the NIH lists prior COVID-19 or current symptoms as exclusion criteria. But World Health Organization (WHO) guidance advises against excluding known cases.


Continued

For volunteer surveys, consent bias is less of a concern if you can achieve high coverage. San Miguel County, Colorado , has processed 2500 tests for roughly 8000 residents.

Another convenience sample is blood donors, though you will still need to collect questionnaire data and people may be less likely to donate when they are ill. But WHO notes that blood donors are a very eager, easy-to-follow population.

So, quick-and-dirty or slow-and-rigorous? I think both have value. The rapid though potentially biased volunteer surveys establish an order of magnitude for seroprevalence (1%, 10%, 50%?) while we await the emergence of more reliable household data.

Studies also collect valuable questionnaire data in addition to basic demographic data. Occupation, travel history, known exposure to a case, and history of clinical symptoms in the months since transmission started are all important. We can use these data to identify risk factors for infection by comparing exposures of infected and noninfected individuals. For example, we may want to identify occupations at highest risk for infection or how frequently transmission within households is occurring.

Finally, surveys are often one-time, cross-sectional studies. But in Miami, 750 new participants are recruited each week (repeated cross-sectional studies). Longitudinal studies, where the same people are sampled every 3-plus weeks, are especially valuable, allowing us to examine antibody dynamics over time to look for waning.

These are some of the key design features for serosurveys. My opinions are informed by WHO guidance on seroepidemiology, discussions with colleagues, observation of what is out there so far, and personal experience with dengue serosurveys.


Natalie Dean, PhD, is an assistant professor of biostatistics at the University of Florida in Gainesville, She specializes in emerging infectious diseases and vaccine study design. Follow her on Twitter.



Medscape Medical News


© 2020 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.



[ad_2]

This content first appear on webmd

You might also like

May 5, 2020 — A roundup of the latest news about COVID-19

Carnival to Resume Some U.S.-Based Cruises

Students Upset by USMLE Response to COVID-19 Demand Changes

Tags: 2019 Novel Coronavirus2019-nCoVbiostatisticsCoronavirusdiagnostics (infectious disease)disasterdisaster medicineFloridaHCoV-229EHCoV-OC43Human coronavirus 229EHuman coronavirus HKU1Human coronavirus OC43infectious disease diagnosticsMarylandpcrpersonal protective equipmentphlebotomypolymerase chain reactionresidencyserologyvaccineWuhan coronavirus
Previous Post

Japan Firm Offers Couples Unused Hotel Rooms Amid Covid-19 Lockdown | Social

Next Post

Disney (DIS) Q2 2020 earnings

Loud Silence Staff

Loud Silence Staff

Related Posts

April 14, 2020 — A roundup of the latest news about COVID-19
US Health

May 5, 2020 — A roundup of the latest news about COVID-19

by Loud Silence Staff
May 6, 2020
US Health

Carnival to Resume Some U.S.-Based Cruises

by Loud Silence Staff
May 6, 2020
Why Clinicians’ Spiritual Health Matters in the COVID-19 Crisis
US Health

Students Upset by USMLE Response to COVID-19 Demand Changes

by Loud Silence Staff
May 5, 2020
As Society Reopens, Not Everyone is Ready
US Health

As Society Reopens, Not Everyone is Ready

by Loud Silence Staff
May 5, 2020
Why Clinicians’ Spiritual Health Matters in the COVID-19 Crisis
US Health

Why Your Kids Should Spend Time Outdoors

by Loud Silence Staff
May 5, 2020
Next Post
Disney (DIS) Q2 2020 earnings

Disney (DIS) Q2 2020 earnings

Recommended

Coronavirus: South Africa allows cigarette sales as lockdown restrictions eased

Coronavirus: South Africa allows cigarette sales as lockdown restrictions eased

April 24, 2020
Cab driver. Harvard dad. Covid victim. (opinion)

Cab driver. Harvard dad. Covid victim. (opinion)

April 18, 2020

Categories

  • African Business
  • African Education
  • African Health
  • African News
  • African Politics
  • African ShowBiz
  • Education
  • Ghana Business
  • Ghana News
  • Ghana ShowBiz
  • Ghana Sports
  • Human Interest Stories
  • News
  • Opinion
  • People
  • ShowBiz
  • Social Trends
  • US Business
  • US Education
  • US Health
  • US News
  • US Politics
  • US Showbiz
  • WADR
  • World Business
  • World News
  • World Politics
  • World Showbiz
  • World Sports

Don't miss it

The Deceptive Life of William Anarfi Sarpong – A Con Artist and Fraudster
Ghana News

Quack Dr. Wask, From Petty Criminal to Gold Fraudster – A Tale of Deception and Danger

March 15, 2025
The Deceptive Life of William Anarfi Sarpong – A Con Artist and Fraudster
Ghana News

The Deceptive Life of William Anarfi Sarpong – A Con Artist and Fraudster

March 14, 2025
The Deceptive Life of William Anarfi Sarpong – A Con Artist and Fraudster
News

The Deceptive Life of William Anarfi Sarpong – A Con Artist and Fraudster

March 14, 2025
NDC unveils campaign team for 2024 General Elections
Ghana News

NDC unveils campaign team for 2024 General Elections

June 19, 2024
A.G Godfred Dame has engaged me at odd hours to implicate Ato Forson – Richard Jakpa
Ghana News

A.G Godfred Dame has engaged me at odd hours to implicate Ato Forson – Richard Jakpa

May 23, 2024
Artiste Profile: Frank Cole aka Zyon Ovkin
Ghana ShowBiz

Artiste Profile: Frank Cole aka Zyon Ovkin

April 20, 2024

About Us

LOGO

Loud Silence Radio & TV Network and is a multi media production company focusing on Ghanaian and African news.

Contact

  • Alexandria, Virginia, USA
  • +1 212-602-9641
  • loudsilenceradio@gmail.com
Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin

Download App

google play store

© 2021 Loud Silence Media. All rights reserved.

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Donate
  • Live Stream
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Menu
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Donate
  • Live Stream
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
No Result
View All Result
  • Ghana News
    • General News
    • Business
    • Education
    • Opinion
  • US News
    • Business
    • Health
    • Human Interest Stories
    • Politics
    • Education
  • Africa News
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
    • Politics
  • ShowBiz
    • Ghana ShowBiz
    • US Showbiz
    • African ShowBiz
    • World Showbiz
  • Editorials
    • People
  • World News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
  • Sports
    • Ghana Sports
    • World Sports
  • WADR
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.