The two had been talking about Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, who is quickly becoming a favorite target of right-wing media.
However, on social media, others thought of another Gretchen: former Fox News host Gretchen Carlson.
Carlson was forced out at the network in 2016 after she rebuffed the sexual advances of then-boss Roger Ailes. The move caused other women to step forward with their own allegations against Ailes, who ultimately resigned.
Pirro was a staunch Ailes defender.
“When I read what was clearly absurdities, in this complaint, I said to myself, ‘How sad that you’ve got this woman who is making these complaints when there are real victims out there,’” she told The Wrap in 2016.
Given that history, a number of Twitter users tagged Carlson ― Gretchen Carlson, that is ― with the clip.
She responded to the “Freudian slip” on Twitter:
It was Pirro’s second unusual moment on the air in a matter of weeks after an eyebrow-raising appearance on her own show in late March.
Twitter users were quick to comment on Tuesday night’s name flub:
Calling all HuffPost superfans!
Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost’s next chapter